Kinzan 金山 Journal
Menu

Expectancy, and why win rate alone tells you nothing

A 70% win rate sounds like a system worth keeping. It can still lose money every month, and expectancy is the number that tells you which one you have.

Expectancy is what you make per trade on average, measured in units of the risk you took. An expectancy of +0.3R means that over a long enough run, each trade returns roughly a third of what you were risking on it. It folds win rate and payoff into one figure, which is exactly why it is more honest than either alone.

Win rate on its own is close to meaningless. A trader who wins 70% of the time but lets losers run three times the size of winners has a negative expectancy and a losing account. A trader who wins 35% of the time with winners four times the size of losers is doing fine. The two numbers only mean something together.

The arithmetic is simple enough to do by hand once: expectancy equals your win rate times your average win, minus your loss rate times your average loss, with both averages in R. The break-even win rate for any payoff ratio is one divided by one plus that ratio, so a system that makes two for every one it risks needs to be right only a third of the time.

Profit factor answers a related question: gross profit divided by gross loss. Above one is profitable. It is useful because it is instantly comparable, and misleading in one specific way: with no losing trades at all it is undefined, not infinite, and a journal that prints a large number there is lying to you.

None of this needs a spreadsheet. If you record an entry, a stop and an exit, every figure above falls out of the data, which is what the journal does the moment you close a trade.

In short

Expectancy
Average result per trade, in R. Positive means an edge, over a large enough sample.
Win rate
The share of trades that made money. On its own it says nothing about whether you are profitable.
Payoff ratio
Average win divided by average loss. The other half of the picture win rate leaves out.
Break-even win rate
1 ÷ (1 + payoff ratio). How often a setup must work just to stand still.
Profit factor
Gross profit over gross loss. Undefined with no losses, never infinite.

Kinzan works all of this out for you

Free. Log an entry, a stop and an exit.